Showcasing the Best of Welsh Business


KPMG Fraud Barometer: Cases in Wales Falls but Value of Fraud Increase Significantly


Wales has seen the number of fraud cases taken to court fall compared to this time last year, but the value per case has increased significantly according to KPMG’s Fraud Barometer. 12 cases totalling £9.8m have been taken to courts in Wales so far this year, compared with 20 cases totalling £9m last year.

There has been a significant drop in the number fraud cases against commercial businesses and government organisations, with the general public making up half of victims in the cases in Wales in the first half of 2019. However, the only Government fraud case has accounted for nearly half the total fraud so far this year (£4.7m).

Professional criminals continue to be the most likely perpetrator with their sophisticated scams accounting for five of the cases, closely followed by managers. Managers have duped organisations out of larger sums of money totalling £6.9m worth of fraud, compared to £2.2m by professional criminals.

Damian Byrne, Forensic lead for KPMG in Wales, commented:

“It’s a concerning trend to see the rise of criminals targeting vulnerable members of the public, including close friends and family.

“Whilst government organisations and commercial businesses have taken steps to counter fraud threats, the risk of fraud will always exist, as seen in the high value cases still coming to court this year.”

Case studies to reach the region’s courts during this period include:

  • A 72-year-old man allegedly obtained £4.7m of European Union and Welsh Government grants by falsely claiming he was developing a plant to breed worms for fishing bait.
  • A 58-year-old solicitor was jailed for six years after he stole almost £1m from the estates of dead people, affecting 16 vulnerable families.
  • A Cardiff couple was jailed for using forged payslips to secure mortgages totalling approximately £1m.
    The National Story

Over £319m of alleged fraud hit UK Courts in the first half of 2019, down from £345m in the same period last year. 217 cases of alleged fraud were heard in Courts across the country, a decrease of 13% on the same time last year, which saw 249 cases.

The Fraud Barometer, which records fraud cases coming to UK Courts with a value of £100,000 and above, noted a worrying commercialisation of cyber-crime and a number of repeat offenders making their way back to court amongst the cases recorded.

Commercialisation of cyber-crime

The Fraud Barometer recorded a number of cases in which the commercialisation of cyber-crime had been a factor – with criminals advertising their services on the dark web.  In one case, a cyber criminal who created a virus and launched an attack which knocked a communications company in Liberia offline, was jailed for 32 months.  He had been paid $30,000 by a rival company to cause the mass disruption – which the victim spent $600,000 repairing.

The data also recorded a 57% increase in the number of account takeover cases reaching court, in the first half of the year where digital scammers used a range of techniques including email, SMS and apps to get hold of personal data that then enabled them to take over bank and credit card accounts. In one case, a Tyneside man who was the UK front of a scam conducted in India was jailed for 28 months at Newcastle Crown Court. The fraud involved online scammers who fleeced vulnerable computer users out of hundreds of thousands of pounds by pretending to help them fix bogus viruses or by hacking attacks on their computers.

Victims, many of them elderly, were panicked into contacting the fraudsters after messages informing them their computers had been infected either popped up on screen or were played through speakers.

When they followed instructions to contact a free number, they were put through to India-based crooks who said they could fix the problem for a fee. But once the scammers had access to victims' banking details, they plundered their accounts and sometimes installed software to allow them to steal more.

Roy Waligora, KPMG UK Head of Investigations observed:

“We are noting a worrying move from criminals simply hacking as a means to an end to being industrialised personal data brokers on the dark web.  As our digital footprints get larger, cybercriminals will continue to develop new and innovative ways to steal personal data. If we are not alive to the threats, there is a great risk that we increase our vulnerability to criminals through our inaction.

The Cyber-Attacks (Asset-Freezing) Regulations 2019 (SI 2019/956) entered into force in June, and require banks to repay funds to customers stolen as a result of account takeover.  Whilst this is a very positive step for the customer, we all need to remain vigilant as consumers will continue to bear such costs indirectly.”

Repeat offenders fail to learn their lesson

Another trend coming through in the Fraud Barometer data saw a number of repeat offenders heading back to Court.  The Fraud Barometer recorded four cases of people with previous convictions for fraud coming back to court under new charges totalling £2.6m. In some cases, the alleged repeat offenders were able to secure employment in new roles where they subsequently were able to circumvent internal controls to continue to commit fraud.

In one case a fraudster was caught trying to pay a £100,000 tax fraud debt with money he had stolen by staging another scam. The 57 year old fraudster first appeared in court in 2016 where he told the judge at Leicester Crown that he could repay the sum of £107,000 if given more time to come up with the money. Investigators from HM Revenue and Customs later discovered he was raising the money to pay the debt through a second scam that involved stealing more than £580,000 from other businesses.  He admitted the second fraud at court in 2019 where he was jailed for four years.

Roy Waligora said:

“Whilst for most fraudsters, being caught and convicted once is enough to ensure they don’t continue to commit crime, for some the lure of the prize on offer is too much to resist – regardless of the consequences.  Businesses need to ensure they are doing thorough due diligence on the people they are hiring into their organisations – particularly if they are filling roles with financial responsibilities.”