Showcasing the Best of Welsh Business


Public Spending Patterns Since Devolution ‘Interesting and Unexpected’


The Auditor General for Wales looks at how public spending has changed over the course of devolution compared to other parts of the UK

In the first decade of devolution, total public spending per head in Wales grew at almost 4% a year in real terms. The public sector austerity that followed saw spending gradually fall. If the pattern of the first 10 years had continued, public spending per head would have been around 40% higher in 2017-18 than was the case. These figures are all set out in a new report and data tool published today.

Overall public spending per head in Wales has been consistently higher than England but lower than Scotland and Northern Ireland over the entire period of devolution. Spending per head in Wales in 2017-18 was £10,587 compared to £11,081 in Scotland, £11,394 in Northern Ireland and £9,247 in England. These figures cover both devolved and non-devolved spending.

There are some interesting and perhaps unexpected variations concerning individual policy areas, for example:

  • In health, until very recently spending per head in Wales had been converging to the lower level seen in England, despite the higher levels of need and overall public funding in Wales.
  • A similar pattern can be observed in education where the consistently higher per capita spending in Wales relative to England seen in the early years of devolution is now far less clear cut.
  • Spending on economic development in Wales has consistently been much higher than in England, and for the early years of devolution was higher than anywhere else in the UK. While it remains significantly higher than in England it is now below the levels in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
  • Spending on culture and recreation grew faster than most other parts of the UK until 2007-08. More recently expenditure has been below Scotland and Northern Ireland, but has remained significantly higher in Wales than in England.

The Auditor General for Wales, Adrian Crompton said today:

“This analysis sheds light on how the public funds spent in Wales have been deployed and the relative levels of spending on broad policy areas. There are some striking findings for public services, policy makers and politicians to consider as they scrutinise the current budget round and for the longer term.

Decision-making in the Welsh public sector is seen through the lens of the Well-Being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015. I hope that by shedding some light on the past, this analysis informs decision making for the future and so will assist those charged with taking forward the next 20 years of devolved government and public spending in Wales.”